Analysis Essay #3 - Key分析短文 3 参考答案

This essay is intentionally named a “Synthesis” (not simply an “analysis”) essay because there is no simple, all-true response to the question of whether grieving should be classified as a psychopathology. Thus, you may align with Allen Frances’ critical assessment or you may support the proposal to include grieving among the criteria for depression disorder. Take care to consider the cultural rituals of grieving about which you are familiar. Regarding Frances’ response, you should identify two or more of the following points raised by him. Making grief a disorder ...
这篇论文故意命名为“综合”（而非“分析”）论文，因为关于哀悼是否应归类为心理病理学的问题没有简单、普遍适用的回答。因此，你可以同意艾伦·弗朗西斯的批判性评估，或者支持将哀悼纳入抑郁症诊断标准的提议。请注意考虑你所熟悉的哀悼文化仪式。关于弗朗西斯的回应，你应该识别他提出的以下两个或更多观点。将悲伤视为一种疾病...

• would be a “wholesale medicalization of normal emotion”
  将是“对正常情绪的全面医疗化”
• would create a huge opportunity for drug companies to market their products
  将为制药公司创造巨大的市场机会
• severe psychiatric symptoms of grief are rare
  悲伤的严重精神症状很少见
• people would not know when to stop taking the drug
  人们不知道何时停止服用该药物
• would interrupt the natural course of recovery from serious loss
  会打断从严重损失中恢复的自然进程
• would reduce the dignity of a life lost and the benefits of grieving rituals
  将降低失去生命的尊严和哀悼仪式的益处